One Question, Two Conversations

Philosophy & science

Reason & evidence

The old question

  • SocratesGreece, about 400 BCE

    The unexamined life is not worth living. Being human means asking hard questions about how you live.

  • ConfuciusChina, about 500 BCE

    You become a good person through practice, and through how you treat family, friends and neighbors.

  • AristotleGreece, about 340 BCE

    Humans are thinking animals that are built to live together.

  • René DescartesFrance, 1637

    I think, therefore I am. Your own thinking is the one thing you can be sure of.

On AI, today

Faith traditions

Belief & practice

The old question

  • BuddhismIndia, about 500 BCE

    The Buddha taught that people can wake up: notice what's going on in your mind, let go of craving, and act with compassion.

  • HinduismIndia, more than 2,500 years

    Each person has a true self, called the atman, that is part of something eternal. Living well means doing your dharma, your duty, with care.

  • Judaism, Christianity & IslamMiddle East, from about 1000 BCE

    These faiths share roots and teachers. They teach that one God made people, so every person has worth. The Bible says people are made in the image of God. The Qur'an calls people caretakers of the earth.

On AI, today

  • World religious leadersHiroshima, 2024

    Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Muslim and Christian leaders signed the Rome Call for AI Ethics, a pledge that AI should serve people.

  • Pope Leo XIVTo U.S. high schoolers, 2025

    Use it in such a way that if it disappeared tomorrow, you would still know how to think.

    Pope Leo XIV on screen above a stage of students at a youth conference Watch Pope Leo EWTN News · YouTube Short (opens in a new tab)

Where they meet

A lot of common ground

  • AI is something people made. It's a tool, not a person.
  • No tool can do your thinking or your choosing for you.
  • People need other people.

Where they split

One big open question

Could a machine ever really think or feel? Many scientists say maybe, someday. Many faith traditions say a person has something, like a soul or spirit, that no machine can have.

People inside each group disagree, too. You don't have to pick a side to decide what you want to keep doing yourself.

Sources